Every service, ranked by real customers

Recently moved their custom-domain email to Fastmail and loves it; Squarespace price rises prompted looking at hosting.

Waited about 12 hours on the trial, then paid for two years; likes the clean interface, fast site and app, and runs aliases and a custom domain.

Support couldn't accommodate a custom webmail subdomain, leaving users confused by the mismatched login domain.

Came over from Proton, tried mailbox.org, and returned to Fastmail; found support great when needed.

On the Fastmail trial after leaving Proton; so far finds few limitations, works with their own domain and masked emails, and likes the clean UI.

Opened tickets about mail providers not receiving their custom domain emails and a billing issue; nine days later neither was resolved, and authenticated mail was still landing in spam.

A couple of years on Proton and it has been fine.

Very happy with Fastmail, with many domains to choose from and masked email used often.

Moved from Proton and Tuta to mailbox.org with a custom domain; fine for years apart from clunky interfaces.

Found Tuta support extremely bad: overcharged, a support post unapproved, and three days for an answer, so they deleted the account.

Picked Zoho over Fastmail for a first custom domain because it was cheaper and after two years has no reason to move.

Left Tuta for mailbox.org and likes it, with third-party app support and a custom domain.

Tuta blocked two paid accounts and one free account, and their card could not be used on a new account without emailing support.

Set up Fastmail on a new domain over a weekend; easy and everything works great.

Four years on mailbox.org without issues, but support could not fix downgrade errors over three weeks.

Moved from Proton to Tuta and really likes it.

Uses mailbox.org with a custom domain; does not love the interface and has heard of sent mail landing in spam, but incoming mail is fine.

A couple of years on Tuta; works great apart from a weak spam filter.

Enjoys Tuta though the UI is disliked by some and third-party clients are unsupported.

Has used Fastmail for several months and likes the 1Password masked email integration. Says the apps just work, has no complaints and considers it great value for the money.

Switched to Tuta and is happy.

Used Fastmail a couple of years before Proton and found it good, but now seems pricier.

Fastmail has been good so far.

Used Proton Mail with SimpleLogin for two years before switching to Fastmail. Found the domain transfer smooth and simple, and has zero complaints about the web, desktop or Android apps so far.

Finds Fastmail's organisation far easier than Proton for a real inbox, and less buggy with a rock-solid app.

Three months testing mailbox.org for the move out of Gmail; very solid and covers the basics and more.

Migrated family to Zoho Mail on a shared domain; works fine and is affordable, though with more spam false positives than Google.

Signed up in 2025 with a custom domain and wildcard; uneventful and as wanted, though mail rules are weak.

Found the mailbox.org UI clunky and dated with no dedicated app when trying to set it up.

About six months on mailbox.org via IMAP with a custom domain and a training spam filter, pretty good.

Switched from Proton to Fastmail for email, calendar and files.

Tuta deactivated their account twice, so they moved to Runbox and had no problems since.

Calls mailbox.org great and cheap with multiple aliases after almost a year and has not considered others.

Nearly got locked out of PayPal because Proton Mail refused to receive the verification code, then moved critical mail back to Gmail.

Says Microsoft 365's built-in backup is super easy to set up and works well.

Migrated from Gmail to Fastmail with easy import and replies from within Fastmail.

Says they have never been able to keep a Tuta account active, paid or otherwise, calling it a dealbreaker.

Seven years on mailbox.org without a single issue across mail, contacts, calendar, tasks and drive.

Uses Fastmail and stopped looking for anything better.

A week-old Tuta account stopped logging in with invalid credentials and the recovery code failed too.

About two years on Fastmail with no problems; everything just works.

After confirming a new Tuta account, the next day login failed with invalid credentials despite correct details.

Uses Fastmail for its features and because other providers accept its mail with less bounce back.

A new Tuta account worked for one day and then returned invalid login credentials.

Could not create a free Tuta account without emailing support, which soured them.

Paid Tuta user since 2019 who is moving to Proton because Tuta caused too many headaches.